I notice, this morning (before tea, even) an incipient wank, and before it really gets going I’d like to throw out some information that, as I’ve become aware, the majority of regular LiveJournal users do not possess.
LJ has announced that it’s introducing an opt-out feature that will allow users to see who’s been visiting their pages; in return, one’s information will be visible to others.
Let’s talk for a minute here about what web sites know about you and what you’re doing. The short answer is, a fuck of a lot.
Things I either know, or could figure out, about you (and when I say you, I mean you personally, Dear Reader, right now — hi!), just from my standard, web hosting provider-installed stats panel on the domains we run (let me emphasize that we do not make an effort to collect this information; we are running the hosting provider’s defaults), include (1) your IP address, which as it appears to me often includes a home or employer domain name; (2) your geographic location (you’ll notice that, as an exercise in publicizing my possession of this information, I put a graphic on the sidebar that shows it, a few months ago); and (3) any page which links back to my domain — including things like, say, the “filter” page LJ builds you when you’re only reading part of your friends list or the amalgamation page Bloglines builds you.
Other data include things like what browser and operating system you’re using (how is that Firefox 3 upgrade going for y’all? I didn’t like it when I tried it), though my current stats package doesn’t associate that data with IP on an individual basis. I imagine, however, that if I were really curious, I could find out, because that information is collected, it’s just not broken out that way in AWStats.
And with what I’ve already got, yes: there are a lot of people out there who, if I wanted to, with the information I’ve got at hand and some very rudimentary social engineering skills (a.k.a. what my mother calls “decent phone manners,”) I could pick up my phone and be talking to your spouse or your boss. This morning. Is that scary? Yeah, kinda. Fortunately for you, I (1) have to take Herself to violin camp and (2) am not a creepy stalker.
Getting this information, these days, does not require mad internet skillz; it requires a username and password (if that; you would be surprised how many people do not think to password the stats panel on their sites), and it shows up on a tidy little screen. And I haven’t played with LJToys (I don’t really need to), but my understanding is that it does similar gathering for LJ-only sites. There is no “knowledge bar” to get over to have access to this data. It is more like a knowledge turnstile with a well-greased pivot.
Is all this a privacy violation? Well, maybe, and maybe not. That’s one of the great questions of the age.
But is being ignorant that you’re distributing this information good? No, I think not.
I have said this before, and I will say it again: online privacy and anonymity, unless you are actively doing something to ensure your security, is a social construct. Think about it for a minute: the internet was built by smart people who wanted to distribute information. And it is very, very good at that. But it is not a particularly good system for ensuring privacy. That’s not what it was designed for. Engineers: they are a literal people.
If you want to retain some degree of privacy, you need to educate yourself (I recommend starting at the Electronic Freedom Foundation site) and take active steps to mask your data. Just because you don’t know how to collect this information does not mean that it is hard to collect. Even off a service like LJ. I collect this kind of information off LJ daily, whether I want to or not (I don’t, particularly. I mostly look at my logs to figure out if someone is hotlinking my photos, because that’s kind of a bandwidth hog. It’s all under a CC license, kids, host it your damn self. And credit).
Me, I’m here to be social, so major violations of the social contract would be counterproductive.
The people you, and I, and everyone else should watch out for? Are the people who aren’t here to be social, and are here to be asses, and think that spreading chaos into people’s offline lives is rewarding in some way. Because they’ve got this information, too. This genie is not going back into the bottle just because you or I or anyone else is standing here going, “Wow, genies are big and scary and I’d rather not see them!”